The MCCQE Part II has Placed a Cap on the First Round of Exams

Below is a rant from a friend in PGY1 of a specialty that diverges from the pack early in residency.

The more I think about the MCC imposing capacity limits for the fall MCCQE Part II, thereby forcing many first years to defer the exam until spring of 2016, the more angry I get. Here's why:

CAPACITY CAPS ARE INAPPROPRIATE

1. The MCC has had ample time to prepare for the high demand

The MCC cites two causes of the high demand this fall:

- No more harmonized exam for family med after 2015
- More candidates in general

The de-harmonization was announced over a year ago. Further, the exam was only harmonized 4 years ago, so the MCC already has experience with a larger volume of applicants.

As for the number of applicants in general, Canadian trained residents make up the majority of MCCQE test takers. The number of Canadian residency positions is easily accessible and is also known over a year in advance.

Despite so much warning, the MCC has only increased fall exam capacity by 7% over last year's fall administration.

2. The MCC's arguments for requiring capacity caps are not supported

The MCC says capacity caps were required to:

- Ensure the integrity of exam scores
- Keep costs down for residents

The MCC has not explained either argument.

Why not hire more people to mark the exam using the extra money from more exam fees? Why not delay releasing the results for a month or so until the scores' integrity has been assured? Why not split the exam into multiple sessions over a few weekends?

As for exam cost, no breakdown has been provided of where our exam fees go, nor how they would be influenced by an increased examinee pool. My impression is that the very steep exam fee of around $2300 should more than cover the cost of one administration. Of course more applicants increase cost (linearly), but they also increase income (also linearly).

3. The MCC is not offering any alternative within a reasonable time frame

The MCCQE is a mandated exam, and it is the MCC's obligation to ensure there are sufficient spots for eligible examinees to take it. This has always been the fall of 2nd year, and by capping spots, they are forcing examinees to wait an additional 6 months beyond that. A couple of weeks I could understand, but not a whole exam cycle.

HOW IS THIS UNFAIR TO RESIDENTS?

1. Many residency programs have a general first year, in part to prepare for the MCCQE.

Therefore, residents who have to defer the exam an additional 6 months are put at a disadvantage. For example, I will have been doing nothing but (specialty) rotations for almost a year before the exam, making it challenging to perform well in a general medicine OSCE.

2. The application process was biased.

An email without any notice was sent out, favouring those with immediate access to the internet and a credit card. Many residents working long hours that day were blindsided as by the time they returned home and checked their email, the exam was already at capacity. The same goes for residents that happened to be on vacation, or residents that needed time to assemble the $2300.00 fee. It also favoured residents on the East coast over the West coast, as signing up at the end of the fday in Halifax is hours earlier than the end of the day in Vancouver.

3. Anxiety
Every resident knows it's stressful to have a major exam looming over them. We had all expected to be done the MCCQE by the end of the year. We now face half a year of more waiting for the test than any group of residents before us.

4. This is the MCC's problem, not Canada's residents'.
I want the MCC to know that they are acting inappropriately. I believe they have failed to address the high demand for their exam properly and are bullying first year residents into accepting their mistakes.